Berliner Tageblatt - Nick Carter Calls Accuser Melissa Schuman a 'Hypocrite' in Court Filings

Nick Carter Calls Accuser Melissa Schuman a 'Hypocrite' in Court Filings
Nick Carter Calls Accuser Melissa Schuman a 'Hypocrite' in Court Filings

Nick Carter Calls Accuser Melissa Schuman a 'Hypocrite' in Court Filings

Backstreet Boys singer Nick Carter has intensified his legal battle with sexual assault accuser Melissa Schuman by filing court documents that characterize her recent efforts to keep her deposition transcript sealed as an act of "hypocrisy." Carter argues that Schuman is attempting to hide evidence while simultaneously engaging in a public campaign against him.

Text size:

Backstreet Boys singer Nick Carter has filed aggressive court documents opposing Melissa Schuman’s attempt to seal the transcript of her April 2026 deposition, characterizing her legal maneuver as a calculated effort to conceal what he describes as false allegations.

In filings obtained by TMZ, Carter directly challenged Schuman’s request to keep the record private, which was made during proceedings where his legal team questioned her about claims that she was assaulted at his Los Angeles apartment in 2003. Carter described her dual strategy of public accusation and private legal protection as the "total embodiment of hypocrisy and regret."

Carter’s documents argue that Schuman acted inconsistently by seeking anonymity now after previously engaging in a "highly publicized defamatory campaign" against him. He contends that for years prior to filing the lawsuit, she showed no hesitation in interfering with his business deals or spreading what he terms "alleged lies" through documentaries and television interviews.

According to the filings, Carter asserts that Schuman initiated her legal action anonymously but later launched a public narrative to vilify him. He claims she "unilaterally and strategically decided" to make these allegations publicly rather than exercising discretion from the start.

Carter further alleges that Schuman’s deposition will expose her claims as a "clear fabrication." In his written arguments, he stated that while Schuman publicly defames him with "horrendous lies," she simultaneously asks the court to shield her from scrutiny regarding what he labels as ongoing fraud and perjury.

"Out of one side of her mouth, [Melissa] publicly defames and vilifies [Nick] with horrendous lies and, out of the other side, asks this court to shield her ongoing fraud and perjury from being exposed," Carter wrote in the documents.

The singer also reiterated his long-standing defense that Schuman conspired with another woman, Shannon Ruth, who has also accused him of sexual assault. Carter claims the two women worked together in an attempt to extort money through false accusations.

Schuman’s lawsuit alleges that the incident occurred at Carter’s residence in 2003. The ongoing legal proceedings involve detailed scrutiny of her testimony and the credibility of her claims, which Carter continues to deny vehemently.

O.Bulka--BTB